AFSCME leader presents inconsistent numbers from strike vote
A strike authorization vote by AFSCME members resulted in only 49 percent voting to authorize a strike, not the 81 percent of members that Executive Director Roberta Lynch announced at a press conference Feb. 23.
“Eighty-one percent of members voted yes to give the bargaining committee the authority to call a strike if no other path forward can be found,” Lynch said.
The vote was held Jan. 30 to Feb. 19. Union leadership didn’t describe result numbers from the vote specifically and didn’t provide the public with the actual percentage when Lynch announced voting results. When asked about specific numbers, Lynch told reporters that they didn’t want to “get into that today.”
“We’re not going to go into specific numbers,” Lynch said.
There are a number of factors that contribute to the total number of workers eligible for a strike and there is disproportionality in the results announced to the public by Lynch. As a vote tally, 81 percent of 80 is gravely different from 81 percent of 100 percent. Yet, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees still claims that “an 81 percent majority of the members of [AFSCME] have voted to give their union bargaining committee the authority to call a strike.”
The problem is not all AFSCME members are eligible to vote and not all AFSCME members are eligible to go on strike. A strike vote is limited to only those workers who are members of the union. So, fair share payers are not eligible to vote.
According to the AFSCME website, “fair share fee payers are not members for governance purposes. A fair share fee payer pays his/her 'fair share' to the recognized organization (AFSCME) for the services it renders to the non-member in its capacity as the exclusive bargaining representative.”
Workers in security positions are unauthorized under state law to go on strike. Because they cannot strike, they cannot vote. There are about 9,000 state employees in security positions at the Corrections and Juvenile Justice Departments.
AFSCME claims to represent 38,000 workers across the state, but subtracting the 9,000 security employees previously mentioned leaves the voting number at a maximum of 29,000.
Using AFSCME’s numbers, the results show 80 percent of the 29,000 workers voted, or a total of only 23,200 workers. Of those 23,200 workers, 81 percent voted to strike. This means that no more than 18,792 workers actually voted to strike.
Additionally, this means only 49 percent of the 38,000 workers AFSCME represents voted to authorize a strike.
When the fair share payers mentioned above are subtracted from the total number eligible to vote, which AFSCME did not release to the public, this percentage drops even more.
Consistent and clear numbers have not been provided regarding worker support for a potential strike.